GOP: The War is Small Town America Vs. San Francisco
Jeffrey Hill | Thu, Sep 4th, 2008 | Category: Commentary | City: Washington, D.C. | Tags: jeffrey hill, environment, san francisco, barack obama, john mccain, gop, politics, rudy giuliani, mitt romney, cities, gay rights, conservatives, minority, womens rights, majority, rnc, culture wars, rural, equal rights, african american, liberals, urban, religion, sarah palin
According to Alaskan Gov. Sarah Palin, who took center stage at the Republican National Convention last night, environmentalists from San Francisco are unpatriotic, uncaring and un-American fascists bent on “turning back the waters and saving the planet” when compared to the truth-loving, chosen people of America’s “small town.” I grew up in a small town and now I live in a city. I’ve been spending the last few hours trying to chronicle my descent into evil.
Former governor Mitt Romney said that the liberal-minded shouldn’t even be in Washington and that conservatives should dominate the entire spectrum of politics.
Former governor Mike Huckabee said that having an African-American presidential candidate is merely “symbolic” and nothing else.
Here’s a news flash for the GOP: By the year 2045, whites will no longer be the majority population in the U.S. and 51.3 percent of the world’s citizens will live in urban areas by 2010. They’re not preaching to the choir anymore, as the Huffington Post inaccurately described – they’re insulting them.
Last night’s RNC speeches were vile, disgusting, insulting and hurtful. I didn’t hear a single suggestion on how McCain plans on taking our ailing economy in a different direction. What I did hear was how I, as a person who tends to be attracted to a more liberal form of politics, should be ashamed of myself. I should hang my head for even questioning the last eight years or having the audacity to believe that gays, lesbians, minorities and women should have equal rights. I should stop living in a city, trade in my bicycle for a Ford Escape and move to Wasilla.
Tell me, Gov. Palin, why am I such a bad person for not believing in your faith? Why are all non-white-christians so wrong? Why don’t I fall for the rallies? Why do I read the “issues” page on your candidates websites? Why did I go to college? Why did my parents, who scrimped and saved to make sure I was better off waste their time working so hard to make sure I was educated? Why didn’t they tell me to resolve my differences with violence and hate speeches?
Tell me Mitt Romney, where should I move to? Since you think I shouldn’t be in Washington, can I move in with you? Maybe we can have a sleepover and you can show me how to be a real American. Can you do me a favor – since you’re asking me to move away from where I work – can you pay my student loans for a few years while I get my red, white and blue back on track?
Tell me Mike Huckabee, what kind of “symbol” are black people? Tell me Rudy Giuliani, how did 9/11 go again? I only lived a few hundred yards from it at the time it happened… When did I get cut from Team America? When did I enjoy riding on a cramped bus trying to get the hell out of there, fearing that another jet was on its way? When did I become such a bad person?
I thought McCain was about reaching across the aisle. Last night, he lobbed a grenade over it. I’m not going anywhere and neither is San Francisco or the other so-called Orangina-sipping cities you painted as “elitist” last night. Start dealing with the issues that will affect a majority of citizens in two years.
Cheat sheet for the GOP. Deal with:
A.) Bridging the divide between cities, suburbs and rural areas instead of defining the war between their cultures.
B.) Investing in clean air technology for large urban centers where millions of people are migrating for employment.
C.) Affordable housing for people who aren’t necessarily white and affluent.
D.) A government that represents the diverse religious, social and economic beliefs of its people.
E.) Changing our economy so that cities and rural areas mutually benefit from trade and new markets and that basic needs like food, water, heat, education and health care are adequately supplied to all.
F.) Reform education so that people have the ability, like me, to fact check your bullshit speeches and separate substance from saliva.
Not one of these issues has been mastered by either candidate. And while neither John McCain nor Barack Obama have taken a real step forward beyond the rhetoric, the GOP took 50 steps backwards – insulting intelligence and pouring salt on the wounds of America.
Disagreements aside, rural Americans and urban Americans are all Americans and we all want the better for our country. These speeches are unhealthy to absorb and I’m worried about children who look at these people as examples. I hope that none of them dreamed of politics last night.
Jeffrey Hill is News Editor for Access Intelligence, a business and technology information firm, web editor for Next American City and a freelance writer based in Washington D.C.








David M in Columbus, Ohio
Thu, Sep 04, 2008 at 11:56am
I’m appalled. You’ve taken quotes from different spots in her speech and combined them in a intellectually indefensible way. She never ever used the word fascist - unless of course you’re inferring that is what she is”
“environmentalists from San Francisco are unpatriotic, uncaring and un-American fascists bent on “turning back the waters and saving the planet” when compared to the truth-loving, chosen people of America’s “small town.”
In addition, she was using Obama’s words against, which is the oldest trick in the political book.
I’m glad I cancelled my subscription to this magazine.
Larry O in Jupiter, FL
Thu, Sep 04, 2008 at 3:07pm
Jeffrey, I felt the same way and so did a lot of people I know and work with. I work at a senior citizen care facility and I was surprised to see that many of them, who are mostly conservative in nature, were completely turned off by last night’s speakers. I think these words are starting to sound ugly to people who are struggling right now.
I think a lot of people understand these divisions now and I don’t think you need to worry about making them aware of it. Let’s stay positive and hope that voters will make the right decision in November.
Chris in Central Texas
Fri, Sep 05, 2008 at 2:16pm
Perhaps your comments come off a bit extreme in nature, but man, if I didn’t find myself rooting for you, thinking, “Jeffrey Hill for President.” Funny thing is, I’ve never even heard your name before coming to this site today. Come to think of it, though, I probably know you no less than I know Barack or John or Sarah through their fluffy speeches.
I’m not very politically driven, so I find myself impatient when watching these acceptance speeches, wondering, “Well, what exactly do you mean by that?” The “that” referring to tax reform, education reform, healthcare reform, all those sorts of things I’ve heard promises to change, but not much of a recipe to show how that change will occur.
I mean, what do you do when you really don’t think either candidate will swoop up and save America from the mess? I guess realize that neither are the second coming of Christ, and hold your breath for the next four years…
Eric S. in Cook, MN
Fri, Sep 05, 2008 at 2:16pm
Thank you! I am sick and f’in tired of hearing about the virtuous Americans who live in small towns and effete elitists who live in cities. I grew up in a conservative, small city of 90,000 and have lived in cities as large as 12 million people. I currently live in a town of 600 people. Those 600 souls are no better or worse than people I have met anywhere else. Some are great; some are awful.
I’m ashamed that I let the Republican noise machine convince me that I don’t love this country. I do love it. I just hate their vision of and for it.
Time to get out there and do something about it.
Jen in Alexandria, VA
Tue, Sep 09, 2008 at 12:23am
I think this is an incredibly inaccurate description of what went down at the RNC (and within individual speeches), and I’m a left-leaning libertarian, even…
In any case, I love NAC and plan to continue reading.
Den in Portland, Or
Wed, Sep 10, 2008 at 11:45pm
They’re “the party that wrecked America”. Haven’t you heard?